|
Date:
April 2000 -
(Download PDF Version)
Topic: Appeals Process
Question: I was wondering if any of your programs have
an appeal process established for when defendants and their
parent/guardian do not agree with the sentence imposed by the
peer court. What do you typically do in this type of instance?
Responses from
Coordinators:
Nancy Anne Livingston
Vilas County Teen Court
330 Court Street
Eagle River, WI 54521
Phone: (715) 479-3749
Fax: (715) 479-1978
nancy.livingston@ces.uwex.edu
If
they refuse it totally they are then directed to set up a court
date to go before our judge. If it is in regards to a portion of
their sentencing the panel members look to me for guidance and
direction and an agreement is met by all parties with the
changes made on the sheet that is then signed, i.e., a youth
asked about not attending the employability class because he had
been working for several years - the panel agreed immediately
and crossed it off the form.
Back to top
Brenda M. Jordan
21st Judicial District Teen Court Director
Assistant Riley County Attorney
105 Courthouse Plaza
Manhattan, KS 66502
Phone: (785) 537-6390
Fax: (785) 537-6334
bjordan@co.riley.ks.us
No, we do not have an appeal process. Our
philosophy and all documentation state that this is a voluntary
program and the parties agree to abide by the sentence. The
option to the offender would be to violate the sentence and then
we would file charges in district court.
Back to top
Peggy Calliham
College Station Teen Court
PO Box 9960
College Station, TX 77842
Phone: (409) 764-3499
Fax: (409) 764-3894
PCALLIHAM@ci.college-station.tx.us
No. Our parents and Teens know going in
what the parameters of the sentence are (the range of hours of
community service, range of number of jury terms and if any
other classes, counseling or apologies will possibly be
required) and they accept them going in. This is an
understanding we have during the interview process with me, the
Teen Court Coordinator before I accept them to Teen Court.
Back to top
Karianne Aaron
J.E.T. Program (Juvenile Empowerment Team)
P.O. Box 458
Sisters, OR 97759
Phone: (541) 549-2302
Fax: (541) 549-2302
KARIA@co.deschutes.or.us
Actually, I have not once in the year that
I have been a Teen Court Director, have a parent(s)
disagree/argue a sentencing. I believe they are thankful enough
that their child has the opportunity for Diversion instead of
going to the Juvenile Department. They have to plead guilty in
the first place, to be a Teen Court participant. They have the
opportunity at any time to leave their trial and be referred to
the Juvenile Department.....so they aware of their choices.
Back to top
Bruce Newman
Genesee County Teen Jury Program
Coordinator
Genesee County Family Court
919 Beach Street
Flint, MI 48502
Phone: (810) 257-3521
Fax: (810) 257-3299
bnewman@co.genesee.mi.us
Our court grants an administrative review
(by a family court judge) of any sentence imposed by the teen
jury if one is requested by a letter from the parent. For
example, sometimes the punishment isn't logistically possible
due to lack of transportation or interference with school
activities.
Back to top
Jean Griffin
Irving Teen Court
P.O. Box 152288
Irving, TX 75015-2288
Phone: (972) 721-3601
Fax: (972) 721-2389
jgriffin@ci.irving.tx.us
www.ci.irving.tx.us/Courts/welcomet.htm
We do not have an appeal process, since
the defendants enter a plea of guilty/nolo contendere to come
through the program, and it is a voluntary program--they ask for
it when entering their plea. Also, we take about 30 minutes per
defendant at enrollment to explain the procedures and counsel
with each defendant and parent regarding benefits of coming
through the program, emphasizing that we are a "sentencing arm"
of the court which does not decide innocence/guilt. Within 24
hours of entering their plea, they may change their minds and
request another deferred program, pay it, etc. Once in Teen
Court, they may drop out at any time, but if they choose to do
so, they do not go back to the judge; we simply return the case
to the regular system and they are notified that the entire
fine/court costs are due and payable. The other benefits of
coming through also disappear-- so that the offense goes on the
record as a conviction, they lose their administrative fee ($20)
and any hours they have worked or jury terms they have served.
Although we occasionally have someone feel their attorney wasn't
"good" or the jury wasn't fair, we pretty much avoid conflict of
this sort, because ALL verdicts are based on our published
discipline grid--so anyone coming through the program knows up
front what the worst/best case scenario is for their specific
type of offense(s). I can see that in those states that allow
Teen/Youth Courts to decide innocence and guilt, there might be
a need for an appeal process.
Back to top
Jeanie Lyles Mitchell
Administrative Office of the Courts
100 Millcreek Park
Frankfort, Kentucky 40601
Phone: (502) 573-2350
JeanieL@MAIL.AOC.STATE.KY.US
Our offenders who wish to appeal just
asked to be referred back to formal juvenile court.
Back to top
Ronald J. (Ron) Shaw
Court Advisor
Springville Jr. H.S.
165 South 700 East
Springville, Utah 84663
Phone: (801) 489-2880
Fax: (801) 489-2885
sron@admn.sjhs.nebo.edu
Our jurisdiction is limited to the
confines of this school. However, we do use an appeals program
that has proven very effective in the 11 years we have been
operating as a peer review court. We allow only two
appeals. The first comes to me, the appellant judge, and if the
defendant is not satisfied with my response, they are entitled
to one more, which takes the case before the principal (our
Supreme Court). In this case, only the record goes forward,
unless the principal calls those involved in. In no case does an
appeal lead to a new trial. The punishment can be dropped or
altered, but not increased.
Back to top
Anne Dubinsky
Lewisville Teen Court
P.O. Box 299002
Lewisville, TX 75029
972-219-3671
fax: 972-219-3414
adubinsk@cityoflewisville.com
If a parent or youth is upset about their sentence in our court
(which is VERY rare), we tell them they can voluntarily remove
themselves from the program and take care of it through
Municipal Court.
Back to top
Nancy Kaplan
Hernando County Teen Court
c/o Clerk of the Circuit Court
20 N. Main Street, Rm 251
Brooksville, FL 34601
Phone: (352) 754-4201
NancyK@co.hernando.fl.us
www.co.hernando.fl.us/ccc/teencrt.htm
We do not. Families are free to leave the
program at any time - even after receiving sentence - and go
through the court system. In the three years and 400 or so cases
that I've been involved with, only once did the family protest
the sentence and they ended up deciding to stay with the program
and accept it.
Back to top
Rosalyn Trumm
Sarpy County Teen Court
1257 Golden Gate Dr., #11W
Papillion, NE 68046
Phone: (402) 593-2207
Fax: (402) 593-2212
ROSALYNT@sarpy.com
In our situation, going to Teen Court is a
voluntary decision for the defendant with the parents approving
of the decision. This decision can be changed at any time. This
is discussed with the defendant and parents at the initial
interview before the Teen Court hearing is even scheduled.
So, if the defendant is not in agreement
with the conditions of the teen jury, they can decide to go
through the formal legal system (usually Juvenile Court). Out of
800 cases, there have been only 4 or 5 situations where the
defendant or parents have not agreed with the sentence,
expecting me to change the conditions. Usually it is the parents
who don't agree with the verdict. When they persist in trying to
put pressure on me, I remind them that their decision is a
voluntary choice and they do have the option of having the file
returned to the County Attorney for prosecution in court. At
that point no one has wanted me to return the file to the County
Attorney.
Conditions are never changed it they are
reasonable and appropriate for the situation, crime, etc. There
have been a few instances where the conditions have been changed
by either me or the judge. e.g. The jury required one defendant
to be on jury duty 10 times. That many times is not feasible.
Another time, a girl with a quite serious reading disability was
required to write a 2000 word research paper. (This was one of
many conditions required of her.) She was still required to
write a paper, but it was reduced to a couple of hundred words.
We try to make any changes in the courtroom with the jury
understanding the reason for the change.
Back to top
Eric A. Albert
Moreno Valley Police Department
22850 Calle San Juan De Los Lagoes
Moreno Valley, CA 92553
Phone: (909) 486-6721
Fax: (909) 486-6750
EALBERT@co.riverside.ca.us
If the teen or parent disagree with the
court the only appeal process is to forward the report to
juvenile probation for handling through the Juvenile Courts.
Back to top
Leslie Comeaux
Keller, Halton City, Watauga Teen Court
7101 Whitley Rd
Watauga, TX 76148
Phone: (817) 514-5823
Fax: (817) 281-1191
lcomeaux47@hotmail.com
We don't have an appeal process. My judges
have mandated that once the defendant receives hours there is no
turning back, so to speak. They have every opportunity before
their actual teen court date to return to municipal court. I
think it is also important to remember that the judges have the
authority to change hours of defendants if they feel it is
either to lenient or to severe.
Back to top
Kirsten Frescoln
Capitol Area Teen Court
PO Box 724
Raleigh, NC 27602
Phone: (919) 856-5591
Fax: (919) 856-5673
kfrescoln@co.wake.nc.us
In Wake, the family has the option to not
sign the Exit Interview Contract which contracts the family and
the agency to do x, y, z listed on the front of the contract. If
the family or youth refuses to sign the contract, the case is
returned to the referring agent for referral to Juvenile or
District Court. Not much of an appeal process but an option
non-the-less.
Back to top
Karen Green
Placer County Peer Court
671 Newcastle Road., Ste 7
Newcastle, CA 95658
Phone: (916) 663-9227
Fax: (916) 663-2965
JGreengolf@aol.com
If a juvenile and/or their parents do not
like the outcome of a Placer County Peer Court Case they can
withdraw from the Peer Court Process and go through the regular
California Juvenile Justice System.
Back to top
Joe Elliott
Buncombe Co. Teen Court
60 Court Plaza, 8th Fl, Bumcombe Co. CH
Asheville, NC 28801-3546
Phone: (828) 251-4959
Fax: (828) 255-5278
jelliott@buncombe.main.nc.us
In our program, clients and their parents
are asked whether they agree to the terms of the sentence
immediately after it has been read. If they do not agree to the
sentence terms, their case is sent back to the referral source.
At that point it is up to the referral source to decide how they
want to proceed; schools may decide to file charges in juvenile
court, and our local Office of Juvenile Justice usually
reschedules the client for a juvenile court hearing. At any
rate, in that situation, the client is no longer participating
in teen court, and has been terminated as "non-compliant."
Back to top
Les Schultz
Brown County Teen Court
P.O. Box 248
New Ulm, MN 56073
Phone: (507) 233-6620
Fax: (507) 233-6649
les.schultz@co.brown.mn.us
Offenders have the choice of going to
court if they do not like the sentence given in teen court. They
do not have any appeal process here.
Back to top
Terry Cannarsa
Blair County Peer Jury Program
423 Allegheny St., Ste. 424
Hollidaysburg, PA 16648
Phone: (814) 693-3230
Fax: (814) 695-0260
Juv509@aol.com
We do not have an appeal process, but have
the parents and juveniles sign a waiver to such action. If the
juveniles don't complete the sentence, we send the charges back
to Court.
Back to top
Russ Landry
S.C.A.L.E.S Project
301 S. Monroe St
Tallahassee, FL 32301
Phone: (850) 488-4265
Fax: (850) 488-4264
landryr@mail.leon.k12.fl.us
S.C.A.L.E.S. Project/Teen Court
Program-Leon County Fl. No appeals process! Jury recommendation
and Judges ruling final, subject to slight modifications in rare
circumstances.
Back to top
Ellen Suni
Kansas City Youth Court
5100 Rockhill Road
Kansas City, MO 64110-2499
Phone: (816) 235-2372
Fax: (816) 235-5276
SuniE@umkc.edu
We don't have an appeal process, but if a
defendant does not complete his or her sentence, the case goes
back to Family Court and they start over again. I guess
this gets them a new proceeding, which is not really an appeal -
more of a denovo opportunity.
Back to top
Gwen Vieau
Orange County Peer Court
17875 Von Karman., Ste 100
Irvine, CA 92614
Phone: (949) 440-6757
Fax: (949) 440-6710
gvieau@crfoc.com
In Orange County Juvenile Peer Court in
California, the parent(s) and juvenile are given the opportunity
to turn down the sentence at the end of the hearing. If this
happens, they do not sign the contract Probation has prepared.
The case is referred back to the Probation Department for
handling. Probation has the option of handling it informally or
turning it over to the D.A. for filing in juvenile court. When a
juvenile does not complete the sanctions given by the Peer Court
jury/judge this is also what happens to the case. The D.A. then
considers that an aggravating factor when filing the case.
Back to top
Olivia Harrington
Duncanville Teen Court
P.O. Box 380280
Duncanville, TX 75138-0280
Phone: (972) 780-5063
Fax: (972) 780-5077
oharrington@ci.duncanville.tx.us
2 choices. They can pay the fine that the
Municipal Judge levied during the plea docket (when they opted
for Teen Court) or if they really raise a fuss, they can appeal
to the county level. But not in Teen Court. I think Metroport
Teen Court has an appeal process and I will forward this request
on to them.
Back to top
Monica Broadhurst
Metroport Teen Court
667 North Carroll Avenue
Southlake, TX 76092
Phone: (817) 481-5581 x840
Fax: (817) 488-5097
MBroadhurst@cityofsouthlake.com
They (parent and youth) are asked by the
adult Judge before their case is heard if they are willing to
accept the sentence given. If when all said and done they do not
agree the only option is for their case to be returned to
Municipal Court. In rare cases where I can see the jury did not
deliberate in a proper fashion I have allowed for another trial
to be given. I explain if this is their choice they must accept
the outcome even if it is harsher than the first. I explain to
them that it is up to their peers and since it will be a
different group of peers they may think he/she deserves a more
severe punishment that the first jury did. If they opt for their
case to go back to Municipal Court the Judge orders them to pay
the citation and it is recorded as a conviction.
Back to top
Lorrain Rutter
Community Accountability Program
120 Strawberry Street
Mercer, PA 16137
Phone: (724) 662-3800 Ext 2561
Fax: (724) 662-4105
lrutter@mcc.co.mercer.pa.us
This is Lorraine Rutter from Mercer County
Juvenile Probation. As part of our Community Court Program the
Juvenile must plead guilty and elect to go through the process
of Community Court. The bonus is that if they successfully
complete the program they do not end up with a juvenile record.
If they decide not to go through the program they are taken
before the Juvenile Court. If they go through Community Court
and do not like the sentence then their alternative is to go
before the juvenile court and take their chances. Due to this
set up we have given them no option for appeal, because we feel
if we do that is allowing them to minimize and not accept
responsibility for their offense.
Back to top
Mary Beck
Midland Teen Court
615 West Missouri, #226
Midland, TX 79701
Phone: (915) 689-1065
Fax: (915) 689-1087
TEENCOURT@prodigy.net
Midland allows them to stay and visit with
the judge that night. If the judge will make a change, we will
accept it. If the judge will not make a change, they have the
option of either completing the sentence as set or going back to
the referring court and paying the fine and keeping the offense
on the record.
Back to top
Deborah Barris
Sacramento Youth Peer Court
2239 "A" Chase Drive
Rancho Cordova, CA 95670
Phone: (916) 363-9402
Fax: (916) 363-9402
peercourt@earthlink.net
Typically, the director consults with
parent and minor after court and if any of the sentence
obligations are impossible or need to be altered slightly due to
financial or transportation limitations...the parent and the
director will make those changes at that time. The director
and/or the judge will initial changes on jury verdict form.
Back to top
Judy Wolfe
Onondaga County Youth Court
555 South State Street
Syracuse, NY 13202
Phone: (315) 435-5707
Fax: (315) 435-1718
ycourt@dreamscape.com
Onondaga County does have an appeal
process, in wrapping up the chief judge tells the respondent
that they have a right to appeal the sanctions of that court and
if they wish to do so they must send a written request to the
Youth Court director within 14 days explaining why they want to
appeal. I then schedule the case to go to one of our other
courts, they can get either the same amount of hours or less.
Back to top
Karlene Peart
Layton Youth Court
PO Box 2103
Layton, UT 84040
Phone: (801) 444-1746
JKPeart@aol.com
In the Layton Youth Court, if they do not
agree, we give them the opportunity to accept the disposition or
refuse it. If they refuse it, they sign a paper stating the
refusal of the Youth Court. If they decide to accept it, they
sign the disposition. If they do not complete it, the referral
is sent back to the referring agency for them to do with it what
they wish.
Back to top
Marcia Frazier
Teen Court, Inc. of Lawton
P.O. Box 1971
Lawton, OK 73501
Phone: (580) 250-1466
Cagirlnok@aol.com
When a parent decides that the sentence
imposed is unacceptable, their case is referred back to the
juvenile bureau to schedule a date to go before the juvenile
judge and plead their case. If they win, there is no charge
involved, unfortunately, if they lose they have to pay court
cost,. Attorneys fees etc. Most of our defendants accept the
sentence that they are given. Of course, they have already pled
guilty to the offense.
Back to top
Joel Clouser
Justice Court 2/YMCA Teen Court
P.O. Box 428
303 Texas Parkway #107
Missouri City, TX 77459
Phone: (281) 403-8080
Fax: (281) 403-8089
clousjoe@co.fort-bend.tx.us
My courtroom is not a shopping mall.... I
do not allow parent and child to shop around for the best deal.
My court sets the punishment. They must sign the Teen Court
contract which says that they will abide by the rules and
sentence of the teen court. To go to teen court I set a $250
deferred fine and the fine is deferred pending successful
completion of the teen court program. Once the program is
completed, the fine is dismissed. If they decide not to abide by
the sentence of the teen court, then they pay the $250 fine.
Back to top
Jennifer Strutz
Stayton/Sublimity Youth Peer Court
362 North Third Avenue
Stayton, OR 97383
Phone: (503) 769-5749
Fax: (503) 769-6408
Jastrutz@aol.com
We do not have appeals in our court. If
the offender and parent disagrees with the sanctions imposed,
the file is then returned to the Marion Co. Juvenile Dept. for
further action.
Back to top
Charles Snyder
Whatcom County Teen Court
311 Grand Avenue
Bellingham, WA 98226
Phone: (360) 738-2457
Fax: (360) 676-6793
csnyder@co.whatcom.wa.us
We do not have an appeals process - since
our process is within our diversion caseload, if a defendant
fails to comply in full with the teen court jury's decision, the
case is referred to the prosecutor for filing, just as with any
failed diversion.
Back to top
Laurie Ocampo
Socorro County Teen Court
Box 157
Socorro, NM 87801
Phone: (505) 838-1206
locampo@sdc.org
Funny you should mention this. This came
up just the other day. If the defendant or parent choose not to
accept the Teen Court verdict, they are simply referred back to
their original referral agency and prosecuted there. But, when
this came up the other day, we had found out that one of our
defendants had perjured himself on the stand. This young man was
sent to us from our local JPPO for criminal trespass. He was
with two buddies (who also went to Teen Court) and he said that
he was cited because he was with them. He testified that he
never actually entered the dwelling. I found out later that that
was a lie. The student participants (jurors and the like), also
found out about this fellow's perjury. The students wanted to
re-try him. Now, I realize that this is not an "appeal", but a
re-trial on the basis of perjury. At this time, we do not have a
mechanism for trying a student on the basis of perjury. However,
there is nothing saying that we can't blaze a new trial in this
area.
Back to top
Don & Linda Zimmerman
Scappoose Youth Accountability Board
P.O. Box "P", 33568 E. Columbia
Scappoose, OR 97056
Phone: (503) 543-3114
Fax: (503) 543-2955
zimmerman@triax.com
Our appeals process is for the juvenile
and their parents to request to be referred back to the Juvenile
Department and have the case heard there. As a Diversion
program we have never had a case appealed. Our process is to
work directly with the Parent and the Juvenile. The Parent and
Juvenile must agree to have the case heard, come committed to
being part of the resolution process, and then be actively
involved in a group process. The Juvenile must admit their crime
before the Board and their parents and take responsibility for
their action. The resolution then is a mediated process
involving the Parents, Board and the Juvenile. The Juvenile and
Parents are actively involved and leave committed to the
process.
Back to top
Bart Thompson
Roy Youth Court
5051 S. 1900 W.
Roy, UT 84067
Phone: (801) 774-1010
Fax: (801) 774-1017
thompsonb@roypd.state.ut.us
We do not have an appeal court. When a
juvenile agrees to go to youth court they must admit guilt and
agree to comply with whatever the peer judges sentence them to.
If they do not like what the judges give them then they can
always go to juvenile court.
Back to top
Marcia Hill
Dodgeville Teen Court
Courthouse
222 North Iowa Street
Dodgeville, WI 53533
Phone: (608) 935-0387
teencrt@mhtc.net
If an offender or family member does not
feel the sentence is appropriate or refuses to comply, they are
simply referred back to referring agency, Soc. Services, Courts,
etc. They may then take their chances through the regular court
system.
Back to top
Eugene Duran
Valencia County Teen Court
P.O. Box 1209
Los Lunas, NM 87031
Phone: (505) 866-8041
Fax: (505) 866-8044
durane@ci.los-lunas.nm.us
Here we go again, impersonating a justice
system. If they do not agree with the sentence then the case is
referred back to referral source. There is no judicial review.
They are disagreeing with a sentence. E.D. VCTC.
Back to top
Scott Gage
Washington County Teen Court
41 East Center Street
Fayetteville, AR 72701
Phone: (501) 521-6809
Fax: (501) 444-1749
LSGage@compuserve.com
In our process here in Washington County,
a child and the parents can opt out of the Teen Court process at
any time. If they decided to do so, they are sent back to
Juvenile Court where they start from square one again. I have
never had anyone choose to do this so far. I have talked with a
few about it. In fact, I talked with one family a week or so ago
who didn't seem really pleased with the sentence passed down.
They decided they didn't want to go back to Juvenile Court
though.
Back to top
Elinor Robin
Broward County Teen Court
1600 West Hillsboro Blvd., Rm 130
Deerfield Beach, FL 33442
Phone: (954) 831-1291
Fax: (954) 831-1296
erobin@17th.flcourts.org
All of our defendants are assigned a
counselor. The counselor has the authority to override the jury.
Usually, the counselor will not override the jury until the
defendant has completed his/her jury duties. We have have found
that if the counselor changes the sentence in any way before the
completion of the jury duties when the defendant is serving jury
duties he/she will tell this to the volunteers who then feel
undermined. Instead the counselor - if convinced the sanctions
should be changed - will tell the defendant to show a good faith
effort by beginning the jury duties and they will discuss it
after the jury duties are completed. In fact, very often, the
counselor, as she monitors the defendant's progress, will change
the sanctions to better suit the needs of the family, the
defendant or the community.
Back to top
Sean Marshall
Cache Valley Peer Court
45W 200N
Logan, UT 84321
Phone: (435) 750-7142
Fax: (435) 787-3586
smarshal@ci.logan.ut.us
We do not have an appeals process,
however, the judges consult with the parent/guardian prior to
making a decision and asked what recommendation the parents have
as it pertains to the sentencing. The parent/guardian is also
asked if they will assist/support the decision once it is
rendered. This has never been an issue. I would say that
if there becomes an issue, the case would just be referred to
juvenile court.
Back to top
Donna Forbes
Reach for Youth
5110 Madison Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46227
Phone: (317) 788-4451
Fax: (317) 780-2560
reach_for_youth@onet.net
Here at Teen Court in Indianapolis we do
not have an appeal process that can be accessed. We have never
had a family express a need for such a process. In fact our
families are so grateful for the Teen Court process instead of
the mainstream juvenile court experience that an appeal process
is not in their concerns.
Back to top
Monica Littlefield
Teen Court of Hopkins County
P.O. Box 1113
Sulphur Springs, TX 75483
Phone: (903) 885-2480
Fax: (903) 885-7813
finsol@koyote.com
If the parents do not agree with the
sentence that the court assigns to the case they have they can
go back and pay the ticket. We have zero tolerance for
that situation. They understood going in and agreed to the terms
of court, so we just let them choose between the hours that were
assigned or to go back and pay the ticket. No appeals at the
Teen Court of Hopkins County, Texas.
Back to top
Kory Norris
Olathe Youth Court
1021 South Pitt
Olathe, KS 66063-2000
Phone: (913) 780-7046
Fax: (913) 780-7045
norrisk.WDSC_PO.WDSC_GWP@mail.olathe.k12.ks.us
Short answer: Olathe Youth Court has no
formal appeal process.
Detailed/practical answer (1-4) below.
- Defendants and their families have
great input in the requirements w/in their jury verdicts.
(Our student-attorneys receive case assignments about 2
weeks prior to youth court session.
- Our student-judges have JNOV power
(judgment notwithstanding the verdict). Thus, the first
place to voice concern is w/ the student judge. If the
verdict is ever altered, we notify jurors and give them
reason for judges' change.
- Olathe Youth Court is voluntary,
thus, defendants and family may withdraw (or be booted for
non-compliance) at any time before I write my 'release'
letter to the DA's office. We have a great relationship w/
DA's office, thus, DA will not allow diversion for students
withdrawing from youth court.
- On rare occasions, I have--with the
input from student-judges/attorneys, altered slightly the
jury requirement, such as, from a personal, face-to-face
apology (when I know that the victim is scared of defendant
and will not face him/her) has been changed to written, with
face-to-face apology to police and/or administration) or
recipient of letter when D will not write to particular
person...)
Back to top
Lisa Albert-Konecky
Mat-Su Youth Court
Wasilla, AK
Our defendants are advised in court that
they have the right to ask for reconsideration of their sentence
then and there. The defendant confers with his/her attorneys,
then will ask for the reconsideration if wanted (with reasons
given). The student judges will then retire to re-deliberate.
The defendant may then accept the sentence or ask for an appeal.
The defendants are also told they have the
right to appeal within three days of court. If so, then their
attorneys are in charge of writing up an appeal stating why the
sentence was unacceptable for the defendant. The prosecution is
allowed to read this statement, then make their response in
writing, then both statements are given to an appeals panel
consisting of youth court judges who were not previously
involved with the case. The student judges hand down a new
sentence, and the sentence is given to the defendant. We
honestly have never had a second appeal, and if that happened,
probably the staff would make an administrative decision as to a
fair sentence, rather than have the case drag out any longer.
Back to top |